Top 10 Controversies in the Electric Vehicle World

The automotive landscape has undergone a seismic shift in the past decade with the rise of electric vehicles (EVs). As these silent powerhouses surged onto roads worldwide, they brought not just the promise of a greener future but also a bevy of controversies, debates, and discussions. From concerns over autonomous driving technology to ethical dilemmas about battery component sourcing, the journey of EVs hasn’t been a smooth ride.

Tesla’s Autopilot Accidents (2016-ongoing)

Image Editorial Credit: Beach Media /

Since its introduction, Tesla’s Autopilot system has been at the center of various controversies due to accidents, some fatal, which were allegedly caused by misuse or system malfunctions. The most publicized incident occurred in May 2016 when a Tesla Model S, reportedly on Autopilot, crashed into a semi-truck in Florida, killing the driver. These incidents raised questions about the safety and limitations of autonomous driving technology.

Nikola Motors Fraud Allegations (2020)

Image Editorial Credit: Stephanie L Sanchez /

In September 2020, Hindenburg Research, a short-selling firm, accused Nikola Motors, an electric and hydrogen truck startup, of fraud. The report alleged that Nikola had misled investors with false claims about its technology and infrastructure. Following the allegations, the company’s founder and chairman, Trevor Milton, resigned.

Dieselgate Impact on EV Transition (2015)

Image Editorial Credit: nrqemi /

Volkswagen’s “Dieselgate” scandal, where they were found cheating on emissions tests, had a ripple effect on the entire auto industry. In the aftermath, as a part of its strategy to regain trust and rebrand, VW aggressively pivoted towards EVs, launching its ID. series of electric cars and committing billions to electrification.

Concerns Over EV Battery Mining (ongoing)

Image Editorial Credit: Sunart Media /

As the demand for EVs rose, concerns grew regarding the ethical sourcing of materials, particularly cobalt, used in EV batteries. Reports of child labor and poor working conditions in cobalt mines, especially in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, put pressure on manufacturers to ensure ethical sourcing.

Tesla’s SolarCity Acquisition (2016)

Image Editorial Credit: IgorGolovniov /

In 2016, Tesla’s acquisition of SolarCity, a solar energy services company, faced criticism and was deemed controversial by many shareholders and analysts. Some believed it was a bailout of SolarCity at the expense of Tesla shareholders. The deal was also criticized for potential conflict of interest, as Elon Musk was chairman of both companies.

GM’s EV1 Program & Its Revival (1996, revisited in 2010s)

Image Editorial Credit: Jonathan Weiss /

While the GM EV1 electric car program mainly took place in the 1990s, the controversy was revisited in the 2010s with the rise of EV popularity. Many believed that GM intentionally sabotaged the EV1 program, leading to the car’s discontinuation. The release of the documentary “Who Killed the Electric Car?” in 2006 revived these discussions.

Concerns Over EV Fire Incidents (ongoing)

Image Editorial Credit: Photo Spirit /

Sporadic reports of EVs catching fire, especially after accidents, have created controversy. Although the rate of fire incidents in EVs is comparable or even lower than that in internal combustion engine vehicles, each reported incident tends to attract significant media attention, raising concerns over battery safety.

Rivian’s Pricing Controversy (2021)

Image Editorial Credit: Tada Images /

In November 2021, EV startup Rivian faced backlash when it announced a significant price increase for its R1T and R1S models. The controversy intensified as some customers who had placed pre-orders were affected by the revised pricing. The company later reversed its decision after the public outcry.

Challenges with EV Infrastructure & “Range Anxiety” (ongoing)

Image Editorial Credit: aslysun /

As EVs became more popular, concerns about charging infrastructure and range limitations took center stage. The term “range anxiety” became popular, referring to the fear that an EV would run out of battery before reaching a charging station. Efforts to expand charging networks and improve battery technology have been ongoing to address this.

Elon Musk’s Tweets & Market Influence (ongoing)

Image Editorial Credit: Frederic Legrand – COMEO /

Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla, is known for his active presence on Twitter. Several times, his tweets about Tesla products, stock, or the EV industry at large have caused market fluctuations and controversies, leading to discussions about the power and responsibility of influential figures on social media.

This article originally appeared on MyCarMakesNoise.

More from MyCarMakesNoise

The Best Motorcycles for Long-Distance Travel

Image Editorial Credit: Dave Smith 1965 /

From classic American cruisers to cutting-edge sport-touring bikes, we’re about to embark on a journey through the world of motorcycling, where comfort, performance, and cargo capacity reign supreme. Read More.

The Best Electric Cars for Eco-Conscious Commuters

Image Editorial Credit: teddyleung /

As technology advances, EVs continue to break barriers, offering ranges that make them perfect for long trips and everyday commutes. Read More.

Unforgettable Motorcycle Routes Across the USA

Image Editorial Credit: digidream /

There’s a sense of thrill and discovery that comes with traversing the nation’s highways and byways on two wheels, and the United States, with its diverse landscapes and epic scenic routes, provides the perfect playground for motorcycle enthusiasts. Read More.

Avatar photo

Author: Dave Johnston

Dave is a hands-on automotive technician with experience in performing service, diagnostics, and repairs on domestic and imported vehicles. He enjoys writing and sharing his knowledge far and wide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *