When shopping for a used car, it’s just as important to know which models to avoid as it is to know which ones to consider. Some vehicles, despite their appealing design and initial popularity, are notorious for their poor reliability, costly repairs, and frustrating ownership experiences. In this article, we’ll explore the worst used cars to buy, focusing on specific models that are known to give their owners grief long after they’ve rolled off the lot. Whether it’s due to mechanical failures, high maintenance costs, or rapid depreciation, these cars are best steered clear of in the used car market.
Contents
Land Rover Range Rover (2003-2012)
The Range Rover is often admired for its luxurious interior and robust off-road capabilities. However, this model is notorious for its frequent and costly maintenance issues, particularly with the air suspension system which often fails and requires expensive repairs. Electrical problems, including malfunctioning dashboard lights and navigation systems, are common. Moreover, engine issues such as overheating and head gasket failures can lead to high repair bills, making older models a risky financial burden for used car buyers.
Mercedes-Benz R-Class (2006-2012)
Mercedes-Benz R-Class combines the comfort of a luxury sedan with the spaciousness of a minivan, but it has been plagued by reliability concerns. Common issues include transmission failures that necessitate costly replacements and engine problems that can lead to unexpected breakdowns. The vehicle’s complex electronics system often requires expert and expensive servicing. Additionally, its poor resale value and rapid depreciation make it an undesirable option for the used car market.
Tesla Model X (2016-2019)
Tesla’s Model X stands out for its innovative technology and electric performance but faces significant reliability issues. The unique falcon wing doors, while impressive, have been prone to mechanical malfunctions that can be costly to rectify. Owners have reported issues with the basic build quality, including inconsistent panel gaps and interior trim misalignments. These issues are compounded by Tesla’s relatively sparse service network, which can lead to long wait times for repairs, making it a less attractive option for second-hand buyers.
Jeep Grand Cherokee (2011-2013)
The Jeep Grand Cherokee is popular for its capability and rugged style. However, models from these years suffer from numerous reliability issues. Transmission failures are frequent, often requiring complete overhauls, while electrical systems show persistent problems, from failing infotainment units to erratic engine behavior due to faulty sensors. These issues detract significantly from the vehicle’s overall reliability, leading to high ownership costs over time.
Lincoln MKS (2009-2016)
The Lincoln MKS, while offering a comfortable ride and a roomy interior, falls short in the competitive luxury sedan market. It is often criticized for its outdated design and lackluster performance. Electrical issues, such as malfunctioning touchscreens and erratic electronic interfaces, are common. Moreover, the MKS has not held its value well, depreciating rapidly and offering little in return for high maintenance costs, making it a suboptimal choice for used car buyers looking for quality and value.
Dodge Journey (2009-2019)
The Dodge Journey offers an affordable entry point into the SUV market but is hindered by its below-average reliability. Common issues include premature wear and tear on brakes and suspension, transmission failures, and a prone-to-fail engine cooling system. It also scores low in safety ratings compared to its peers. The combination of these factors results in a vehicle that is likely to incur high repair costs and provide a disappointing ownership experience.
Chrysler 200 (2011-2017)
The Chrysler 200 is often seen as an attractive mid-sized sedan with a competitive initial price point. However, it is notorious for its transmission issues, particularly with the nine-speed automatic that suffers from jerky shifts and reliability problems. Engine reliability is also a concern, with instances of unexpected shutdowns and power loss. Coupled with a cramped interior and poor long-term durability, the Chrysler 200 is frequently overlooked by savvy used car buyers.
Land Rover Discovery (2004-2009)
The Land Rover Discovery is celebrated for its adventure-ready capabilities and classic British design. However, these models are fraught with issues, including chronic air suspension failures that lead to expensive repairs and a cooling system prone to leaks and overheating. Electrical gremlins in the dashboard and infotainment systems are also common, adding to the overall maintenance burden. These reliability issues make the Discovery a less desirable choice for those looking for a dependable used SUV.
Mercedes-Benz GL-Class (2007-2012)
The GL-Class is Mercedes-Benz’s answer to a full-sized luxury SUV, offering ample space and comfort. However, it suffers from high maintenance costs associated with its air suspension system, which is prone to failures and expensive to fix. Engine issues, including turbocharger and seal failures, can lead to costly repairs. Additionally, the GL-Class depreciates quickly, losing value faster than many of its luxury SUV counterparts, making it a poor investment for used car buyers.
Tesla Model S (2012-2016)
The Model S is a revolutionary electric vehicle offering high performance and a sleek design. Early models, however, have been criticized for issues such as unreliable door handles, which often fail and are costly to replace. Battery life inconsistency and deterioration can also affect vehicle range significantly. Interior build quality issues, such as peeling trim and misaligned panels, detract from the premium feel expected from Tesla, making early Model S vehicles a gamble in the used car market.
Jeep Patriot (2007-2017)
The Jeep Patriot is designed to offer an affordable entry into the SUV market but is hampered by its lackluster performance and poor build quality. Transmission problems, particularly with the CVT, are widespread and can lead to complete failures necessitating expensive repairs. The vehicle’s engine is also known for its lack of power and durability issues, including frequent oil leaks and cooling system failures. Combined with a basic and uncomfortable interior, the Patriot offers little appeal in the competitive used car market.
Lincoln Navigator (2007-2014)
The Lincoln Navigator of these years offers luxury and space but at the cost of reliability. Owners frequently face issues with the air suspension system, which is prone to failure and results in costly repairs. Electrical problems, including erratic behavior of the infotainment and navigation systems, add to the owner’s frustrations. Engine issues such as faulty ignition coils and leaking oil seals can lead to expensive mechanical repairs, making the Navigator a less desirable choice for those looking for a reliable used luxury SUV.
Dodge Nitro (2007-2011)
The Dodge Nitro attracts buyers with its bold design and robust stance, but it falls short in terms of reliability and overall quality. Engine reliability is a major concern, with many reports of overheating and head gasket failures. Transmission issues, particularly with the automatic gearbox, which can fail prematurely requiring complete replacements, are significant. The vehicle’s interior is also noted for its poor-quality materials and uncomfortable seats. These factors make the Nitro a less favorable option for buyers in the used car market.
Chrysler PT Cruiser (2001-2010)
This uniquely styled vehicle initially gained popularity for its retro design, but the Chrysler PT Cruiser is plagued by a range of mechanical and reliability issues. Engine problems, such as oil leaks and timing belt failures, are common and often result in costly repairs. The cooling system is also problematic, with frequent radiator failures. Additionally, the PT Cruiser’s electrical system is unreliable, with issues like failing power windows and malfunctioning air conditioning systems. These problems, combined with a cramped interior and poor fuel economy, make it a poor choice for a used car.
Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class (2014-2018)
The CLA-Class is Mercedes-Benz’s attempt at a compact luxury sedan, but it is often criticized for not living up to the brand’s standards of luxury and comfort. The ride quality is considered too harsh for a luxury sedan, and the interior space is cramped, particularly in the rear seats. Mechanical issues include problematic transmissions and sensitive electronic components that frequently require dealer attention. These factors contribute to its lower desirability as a used car.
This article originally appeared on MyCarMakesNoise.
More from MyCarMakesNoise
20 Cruisers Suited for Riders at Any Skill Level
Cruiser motorcycles are a popular choice for riders of all skill levels, offering a blend of style, comfort, and performance. Whether you’re just starting your riding journey or you’re a seasoned veteran, the right cruiser can make all the difference. Read More.
15 Luxury Sedans for Comfortable Road Tripping
Setting off on a long road journey requires a car that excels in comfort, performance, and luxury. High-end sedans stand out as perfect candidates, offering spacious interiors, cutting-edge technology, and smooth handling. Read More.
Harley-Davidson`s 20 Biggest Flops
Harley-Davidson, a cornerstone of American motorcycle culture, is known for its powerful engines and distinctive designs. However, even this iconic brand has had its missteps. Read More.
