Harley-Davidson, a cornerstone of American motorcycle culture, is known for its powerful engines and distinctive designs. However, even this iconic brand has had its missteps. This article takes a candid look at some Harley models that missed the mark due to engineering flaws or poor design choices, offering a rare glimpse into the challenges of maintaining a legendary reputation in the dynamic world of motorcycling.
Contents
HD Street 500
The Street 500 was aimed at a younger market but fell short in many areas. It was criticized for poor build quality, with parts that felt cheap and flimsy. Its engine was also underwhelming, with only 494cc and about 35 horsepower. Some riders found the bike uncomfortable, particularly on longer rides.
2002 V-Rod
While innovative in some respects, the V-Rod’s liquid-cooled engine was a departure from the traditional Harley style. It lacked torque at low RPM, leading to a less satisfying riding experience for some Harley enthusiasts. Its futuristic design was also divisive.
2001 Ultra Classic
The 2001 Ultra Classic faced complaints for its Twin Cam 88 engine, known for its cam chain tensioner problems. This could cause significant engine damage if it failed. Many riders were displeased with the build quality and reliability, and some found that the bike handled poorly, especially at higher speeds. This led to a general perception of the model as being subpar compared to others in the Harley lineup.
Livewire
Harley’s Livewire, their first electric motorcycle, faced criticism for its high price point and limited range of only about 140 miles on a full charge. While it was praised for its performance and handling, the limited charging infrastructure and the contrast with Harley’s traditional image created barriers for many potential customers.
2014 Electra Glide
The 2014 Electra Glide was involved in a recall due to a clutch issue that could cause the bike to lose the ability to generate enough lift to disengage the clutch. This issue could increase the risk of a crash, particularly at low speeds. Some riders also complained about the infotainment system being too complex and the bike’s overall weight, which affected handling.
2017 883 Iron
While not exactly a disaster, many riders felt that this bike’s engine was underpowered for its size, making it lackluster in terms of performance. Some also complained about the seat’s comfort over long distances.
2009 FLHTCUSE
Part of the CVO line, this model suffered from engine heat issues, especially in traffic, making it uncomfortable for riders. Moreover, its price didn’t align with the features offered, leading to dissatisfaction among buyers.
2016 Harley-Davidson Road Glide Ultra
The 2016 Road Glide Ultra was criticized for its excessive weight, which affected its handling and maneuverability, especially in urban environments. While the bike offered a comfortable ride with features like a powerful infotainment system and plush seating, its 425-pound weight made it less appealing for riders looking for a more agile touring experience. Despite its robust 103 cubic-inch engine, the bike’s bulk was a significant drawback for many.
2007 Harley-Davidson Night Rod
The Night Rod version of the V-Rod family introduced in 2007 featured a darker, more aggressive styling and a slightly detuned engine for better mid-range torque. However, it was criticized for its riding position, which was uncomfortable for long distances, particularly because of the forward foot pegs and low handlebars. Although it tried to appeal to a younger audience with its modern design, traditional Harley riders found it too radical.
1998 Harley-Davidson Dyna Wide Glide
The 1998 Dyna Wide Glide was criticized for its excessive vibration at highway speeds, which detracted significantly from rider comfort. Equipped with a 1340cc Evolution engine, the bike struggled with stability, making long rides less enjoyable. Its flashy design, characterized by a long rake and flamboyant styling, was not enough to offset its performance shortcomings.
2010 Harley-Davidson XR1200X
While aimed at attracting a European audience with its sportier stance, the XR1200X did not perform as expected. It was heavier than its competitors in the sportster segment, and its 1200cc engine, while robust, did not provide the agility or power-to-weight ratio that riders sought in a performance-oriented bike.
2006 Harley-Davidson Street Rod
The Street Rod, a variant of the V-Rod, was supposed to offer a more refined ride with better ergonomics and handling. However, it was criticized for a seating position that was too aggressive for long rides and a high center of gravity that made low-speed maneuvers challenging. The 1130cc engine, while powerful, did not compensate for the bike’s handling difficulties.
2004 Harley-Davidson Sportster 883
The 2004 edition of the Sportster 883 was often noted for its lack of power and rough ride quality. Despite its iconic status, this model was particularly hard-hit by criticisms of the Sportster line’s notorious vibrations and uncomfortable stock seat, which made it less appealing for new riders or those looking for a smooth cruising experience.
2002 Harley-Davidson Fat Boy
The 2002 Fat Boy received backlash for its poor fuel system, which led to frequent stalling and reliability issues. Although it featured the classic Harley styling and a 1450cc Twin Cam engine, the mechanical problems significantly undermined its performance and customer satisfaction.
2007 Harley-Davidson Softail Custom
This model faced issues with its Twin Cam 96B engine, particularly concerning durability and oil pump problems. The bike’s custom aesthetics couldn’t mitigate the frustrations owners felt regarding frequent maintenance needs and the potential for significant engine failures.
1997 Harley-Davidson Electra Glide
The 1997 Electra Glide struggled with electrical issues that affected its ignition and lighting systems, leading to reliability concerns. The touring bike, despite its comfortable ride and suitable features for long-distance travel, frequently left riders dealing with unexpected repairs.
2005 Harley-Davidson Deuce
The Softail Deuce was criticized for its rear suspension, which offered limited travel and poor absorption of road imperfections. Combined with a rigid frame, the ride quality was harsher than expected for a cruiser, deterring riders who prioritized comfort.
1996 Harley-Davidson Road King
The 1996 Road King aimed to blend the classic Harley styling with touring capabilities, featuring a 1340cc Evolution engine. However, it was criticized for its carburetor issues, which led to inconsistent performance and starting problems, particularly in cold weather. Additionally, riders noted that the bike’s large size and weight made low-speed handling difficult, a significant concern for a motorcycle intended for long-distance comfort.
1991 Harley-Davidson Sportster 883 Deluxe
The Sportster 883 Deluxe from the early ’90s faced difficulties with its vibration levels at high speeds, which were uncomfortably pronounced due to the solid engine mounts used at the time. This made long rides less enjoyable and contributed to rider fatigue. Furthermore, its relatively modest power output left it feeling underpowered compared to competitors, limiting its appeal to those looking for a more robust riding experience.
2015 Harley-Davidson Street 750
The Street 750, like its smaller counterpart, the Street 500, aimed to capture a new segment of urban riders and was a part of Harley-Davidson’s strategy to appeal to younger consumers globally. However, it was criticized for its build quality, which many felt did not meet the standards typically associated with the Harley-Davidson brand. The braking system, in particular, was a point of contention, with early models suffering from inadequate braking power until a recall was issued to address this safety concern.
This article originally appeared on MyCarMakesNoise.
More from MyCarMakesNoise
The Top 20 Bestselling American Cars in History
Throughout this journey, certain models have captured the hearts of consumers more than others, selling in astounding numbers and carving their names into automotive history. Read More.
The Best Midsize Truck Options You Can Buy
From hauling heavy loads to off-road escapades, mid-size pickup trucks are the versatile workhorses bridging the gap between larger, more cumbersome trucks and smaller, less capable vehicles. These trucks have rapidly grown in popularity, offering the perfect blend of utility, comfort, and performance. Read More.
Classic Cars That Illuminate with Pop-Up Headlights
These iconic features not only served a functional purpose but became emblematic of automotive design during the late 20th century. Read More.
